Celtic Ps and Qs
Posted by Shae on November 17, 2002
In Reply to: Prehistory of Basque posted by R. Berg on November 17, 2002
: : : : : : : : : : : I am US-born, but my father was from Glasgow, and he often used this term. I took it to mean a sort of cocky, dandy, self-confident sort of fellow. Does it refer to some historical figure or is it just a generic, British idiom?
: : : : : : : : : : I think it's generic, rather than historical. You're right about cocky and self-confident, but less so about dandy. A Jack the lad is also somewhat roguish, a person who gets up to minor sins and maybe even minor crimes, albeit the expression is more fond than pejorative - you usually can't help but like a Jack the lad. I have no proof at all, but I suspect the expression arose from the joining of two separate terms - in the UK, "Jack" was used to refer to the ordinary man in the street, as in "I'm all right, Jack" (a little like the US usage of Joe, as in he's a regular Joe, I suppose). Similarly "lad" in the UK is still used to describe someone who's loud and boisterous - "he's a bit of a lad" and "laddish" are commonly used to this day. We even have the recent coinage of "ladettes" to describe lager-swilling brash twenty-something girls out in droves at night.
: : : : : : : : : Speaking of which, why is the British flag called the Union Jack? Or maybe it's The Union, Jack? :)
: : : : : : : : Strictly speaking, it's only called the Union jack when it's flown on a boat or ship. At all others times it should correctly be referred to as the Union flag. Jack in this sense is a generic word for any flag flown from a ship (attached to a jackstaff, usually), although especially one that denotes nationality. As to the Union part? The flag is a amalgamated overlay of the cross of St. George (patron saint of England), the cross of St. Andrew (patron saint of Scotland) and the cross of St. Patrick (patron saint of Ireland). The Welsh don't get a look-in with their dragon, maybe because they were never a kingdom as such, or maybe because it was just too hard to incorporate.
: : : : : : : : More detailed flag information on the Union flag available at the link below (which I've just noticed answers the Welsh issue).
: : : : : : : Paradoxically, TheFallen is not wrong, and yet, not right. Wales was briefly a kingdom.
: : : : : : : The Kings were Rhodri Mawr (Rhodri the Great), Hywel Dda (Hywel the Good), Gruffudd ap Llywelyn (1039-63), Llywelyn ap Iorwerth (Llwyelyn the Great) (1194-1240) and Llywelyn ap Gruffudd (1248-82).
: : : : : : : However, TheFallen said Wales was never a "kingdom as such" which tells me he's taking the long view of Wales varied history.
: : : : : : : Moving from world history to word history, _The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language_ provides the following:
: : : : : : : "Although Celtic-speaking peoples were living in Britain before the arrival of the invaders from Friesland and Jutland whose languages would eventually develop into English, it was the Celts and not the invaders who came to be called "strangers" in English. Our words for the descendants of one of the Celtish peoples, Welsh, and for their homeland, Wales, come from the Old English word wealh, meaning "foreigner, stranger, Celt." Its plural wealas is the direct ancestor of Wales, literally "foreigners." The Old English adjective derived from wealh, wælisc or welisc, is the source of our Welsh. The Germanic form for the root from which wealh descended was *walh-, "foreign." We also have attested once in Old English the compound walhhnutu in a document from around 1050; its next recording appears in 1358 as walnottes. This eventually became walnut in Modern English, which is thus literally the "foreign nut." The nut was "foreign" because it was native to Roman Gaul and Italy."
: : : : : : : This foreign nut thinks she'll read some Dylan Thomas this weekend.
: : : : : : It's not unusual...
: : : : : I promise not to throw my knickers, or even jocks, at Ms Camel. The etymology of 'Wales' caused my ears to prick. Surviving Celtic languages had/have two dialects - Goedelic and Brythonic. Until Roman times, the inhabitants of present day England and Wales spoke Brythonic. Some of the southern English 'tribes' migrated to northern France during the 5th century and established a small territory there, known today as Brittany. Roman geographers, recognising the cultural link between the two places, referred to the island as Greater Britain and to northern France as Lesser Britain.
: : : : Breton is still occasionally spoken in northwestern France, I believe, albeit that it's dying out fast.
: : : : I think I'm right in saying that Cornwall was also a Celtic foothold, and that the Cornish language a further variant of the Celtic language. Tragically, the last person who knew authentically how to speak Cornish died a few years ago, so although the language is still known through written work, its pronunciation is now a matter of guesswork.
: : : : Didn't the Celts also head down into the Pyrenees and beyond? Basque is a Celtic-based language as well, I'm sure.
: : :
: : : The Basque people, their culture and language predate, by at least 1,000 years, the arrival of the Celts.
: : The last I heard, linguists had not been able to connect the Basque language, analytically, with any other language. Its origin is a mystery.
As far as I know, Basque and Finnish are the only European languages that don't have an Indo-European origin.
Linguists recognize six Celtic language variants that fall into two categories: Q-Celtic and P-Celtic. The former comprises Gaelic (Irish), Gadhelic (Scottish) and Gaelg (Manx), and the latter Cymraeg (Welsh), Kernewek (Cornish) and Brezhoneg (Breton). The last native Manx speaker died in 1974, while spoken Cornish disappeared in the 18th century. Attempts to revive both are underway. Fortunately for Manx revivalists, old recordings of native speakers provide pronunciation guidelines. Their Cornish brethren are helped by similarities in pronunciation between the two extant P-Celtic languages but, as TheFallen suggests, much is guesswork.
Main source: MacKillop, James, "Oxford Dictionary of Celtic Mythology,' OUP, 1998