A laughing-stock is a person or thing that everyone makes fun of, usually because they have tried to look serious or important and failed. The phrase has been in English since the 1530s. The ‘stock’ is not the stocks used as a punishment but an old word for a post or stump, so a laughing-stock is simply the butt of the laughter.
What’s the origin of the phrase Laughing-stock?
Laughing-stock is now usually written as a single hyphenated word, but it was previously the two-word phrase, ‘laughing stock’.
It’s moderately old and there are at least two citations of it dating back to the 16th century. John Frith’s, _An other boke against Raste_l, 1533:
“Albeit … I be reputed a laughing stock in this world.”
and Sir Philip Sidney’s, An apologie for poetrie, written in 1581 and first printed in 1595:
“Poetry … is fallen to be the laughing stocke of children.”
Sidney, who was born in 1554, could not have written it in 1533. Henry Morley’s 1891 edition of the work, A Defence of Poesie and Poems, says Sidney “wrote in 1581 this piece, which was first printed in 1595, nine years after his death”. In Morley’s modernised text the line reads: “poor poetry, which, from almost the highest estimation of learning, is fallen to be the laughing-stock of children”.
Shakespeare used the plural. In The Merry Wives of Windsor (Act 3, Scene 1), Sir Hugh Evans says aside to Doctor Caius, the man he is supposed to be fighting: “Pray you, let us not be laughing-stocks to other men’s humors.”
The age of the phrase may be the reason that it is often linked with the practice of putting people into stocks as a punishment. The stocks were a means of punishment in use at the time the phrase was coined, by which people were tortured or ridiculed. Victims were held by having their ankles, and occasionally the wrists too, trapped in holes between two sliding boards. The punishment, although not as harsh as the pillory, in which people were confined by the neck, was severe and certainly not intended to be humorous.
Stocks and pillories are no longer used a means of punishment. More recently, it’s become commonplace at school fairs and charity events to put volunteers into stocks and pillories and throw wet sponges at them. This is for humorous effect of course and has no doubt added to the idea that ‘laughing-stock’ originated this way.
The stock in question isn’t that though. It refers to the meaning of stock as ‘something solid that things can be fixed to’, that is, a butt or stump. So, ‘laughing-stock’ is just the same as ‘the butt of the joke’.
It may be that the association between ‘laughing-stock’ and the practice of ridiculing people in the stocks grew over time. There’s no reference to that in any of the early citations of the phrase though, and it seems clear that isn’t the way the phrase originated.
The Cambridge Dictionary’s definition catches that same note of failed dignity: a laughing stock is “someone or something that seems stupid or silly, especially by trying to be serious or important and not succeeding”. Being made a laughing-stock is, as another phrase puts it, ‘no laughing matter’.
