phrases, sayings, idioms and expressions at

Phrases, Sayings and Idioms Home > Discussion Forum

Translation is not necessarily close to the original

Posted by RRC on October 15, 2007

In Reply to: Re: Silence is golden posted by ESC on April 13, 2001 posted by Tula on October 15, 2007

: There is a Cervantes quote in Don Quixote
: "'[A]s Sancho says, silence is golden.'
: 'That must be some other Sancho,' said Don Quijote." Volume 2, Chapter 43, pg. 584

This is the speech of the translator thus cannot be dated to the time of Cervantes but to the the time of the translation. A different translation says:

'sage silence is called Sancho.'"
"That, Sancho, thou art not," said Don Quixote;