Re: Etched In Stone

Posted by ESC on May 14, 2000

In Reply to: Etched In Stone posted by jean on May 14, 2000

: Is the correct saying

: "It is not etched in stone" or is it

: "It is not etched in granite"

: which is the correct way to say that cliche
: stone or granite which way have you heard it most referred to.
: Thank you.

I vote for "etched in stone." And "Slang: the Authoritative Topic-by-Topic Dictionary of American Lingoes from All Walks of Life" by Paul Dickson (Pocket Books, New York, 1990, 1998) agrees with me. In the "Bureacratese" chapter, it has "etched in stone. Cannot be changed, but often stated in the negative: 'This plan is not exactly etched in stone.'"

It has an expression I've never heard. The opposite: "etched in sand. Flexible."