Posted by R. Berg on January 15, 2003
In Reply to: Don't shoot until you see the whites of their eyes. Earliest quote posted by James Briggs on January 15, 2003
: The Times publishes a regular Q&A column, often about the
origin of sayings and phrases (I've had several answers published).
: A recent question was about the saying "Don't shoot until you see the whites of their eyes"? Some answers have been published, but one today seems to put the origin back 32 years from the accepted version. I thought it worth while passing on. The text come directly from the newpaper, and I thus acknowledge its source.
to your previous correspondence (Q&A, December 30), which attributes the saying
to the American General William Prescott, at the Battle of Bunker Hill ill 1775,
this phrase is actually recorded some 32 years earlier.
: At Dettingen, Flanders, on June 27, 1743, Lieutenant-Colonel Sir Andrew Agnew of Lochnaw (5th Baronet) gave to the men or his regiment, the 21st of Foot, an order from which this saying is derived. A man of spirit even for the times, he had earlier in the day replied to a brigade order that "the scoundrels will never have the impudence to attack the Scots Fusiliers", but they did.
: Formed in square, the Scots Fusiliers held a steady fire rolling along their lines and kept off the advancing French infantry.
: Sir Andrew, a resourceful and experienced officer, had in training practised a novel battle drill with the men in his square, should they be attacked by cavalry.
: At last, the opportunity to spring this trap appeared when the square was attacked by enemy cuirassiers. Instead of employing the orthodox tactic of seeing them off by standing firm and taking the charge on muskets and pikes, Sir Andrew gave orders that, as the cavalry approached the front line, the two centre companies should divide from the centre and fall back from the outer markers. This novel approach allowed the cavalry to charge through a lane with the Fusiliers facing inwards. At this point Sir Andrew gave the command:
: "Dinna fire till ye can see the whites of their e' en . . . if ye dinna kill them they'll kill you." The French, as they rode through this lane of soldiers, were subjected to a withering crossfire and destroyed.
: Later in the day King George II, who commanded the Army but was a little out of his depth, rode up and said: "So, Sir.
: Andrew, I hear the cuirassiers rode through your regiment today."
: "Ou, ay, yer Majestee," was the reply "but they didna get oot again."
: This account is extracted from an article in the Journal of the Royal Highland Fusiliers Volume 24, No 2 (Winter 2000) and written by Sir Andrew's descendant, Major Sir Crispin Agnew of Lochnaw, Bt.
: Dr J. R. Donald. Glasgow"
I can't help wondering whether the two-row configuration wouldn't have caused some casualties for the home team. Anything less than perfect marksmanship by a Fusilier and his shot might hit a comrade opposite him.