Re: Oxyslurs/ethnomorons
Posted by R. Berg on November 05, 2001 In Reply to: A Rose by any other......
posted by Bruce Kahl on November 05, 2001
: : : : : : : : What is meant by the phrase "gypsy's warning"?
: : : : : : : The only gypsy warning that I'm familiar with is
the one in "The Wolf Man," a 1941 movie. See http://rhs.jack.k12.wv.us/classic/feature/wolfman/wolfsb1.htm
: : : : : : gypsy's/gipsy's warning n.1 [mid-19C+] no warning at
all. [neg. stereotyping]
: : : : : : gypsy's/gipsy's warning n.2 [mid-19C+] morning. [Rhy.
sl.]
: : : : : : From _Cassell's Dictionary of Slang_ (1998) by Jonathon
Green
: : : : : So, "gypsy's warning" is an ethnic slur along the lines
of "Mexican standoff" and "Dutch treat." (Search archives under
"standoff" and "treat.")
: : : : "Ethnic slur" sounds so harsh... and they are oxymorons,
: : : : most obvious examples - Dutch Courage, Military Intelligence,
: : : : modern parallels - perhaps the warnings phoned in by terrorists
3 minutes before an attack.
: : : Yes, "ethnic slur" is very harsh cause the phrase IS an ethnic
slur and an oxymoron it is not.
: : : An oxymoron ( Greek: Oxus = "sharp" Moros = "dull" ) is a
combination of contradictory or incongruous words such as "jumbo
: : : shrimp", "definite maybe", "exact estimate","army intelligence"
: : : etc etc.
: : : An ethnic slur is the attribution of negative, sarcastic,
humiliating and demeaning traits to human beings based on their
place of birth, race or creed aka "regional chauvinism".
: : : In fact, the English word "gyp" which means to swindle or
defraud is derived from Gypsy and "gyp" is an ethnic slur the same
as "Gypsy' warning".
: : and Dutch Courage is still an oxymoron, since the implication
is that the dutch have no courage and hence need it from alcohol,
therefore "dutch" and "courage" are incongruous words placed together,
as for that matter are "Gypsy" and "warning".
: "Ok, I see" sez the blindman.
: Hateful oxymora?
: I found a dictionary that said an oxymoron:
: "..is a wittily paradoxical turn of phrase that appeals to 'unconscious
responses instead of rational examinations.'
: So I agree with you then that these hate terms could be considered
oxymoronic but I see the hate before the wit!
Either "gypsy's warning" is both an ethnic slur and an oxymoron,
or it is neither. Proof? Here goes: If it's an oxymoron, it qualifies
as one by juxtaposing two logically incompatible terms. For the
terms "gypsy" and "warning" to be incompatible, the phrase must
presume an inconsistency between gypsies and warnings. We all know
that warnings are good things. Therefore the problem must be with
gypsies--they don't give warnings, or they give false ones, or untimely
ones, or whatever. And that premise is the ethnic slur (or, as a
reference book cited above calls it, the negative stereotyping).
If there is no ethnic slur--that is, if the phrase doesn't imply
a blanket attribution of some bad quality to gypsies as a group--then
there's no inconsistency between "gypsy" and "warning," and the
phrase is not an oxymoron. (In this condition the phrase is also
pointless.)
The world is currently in a crisis of the utmost severity that
began with the same "My group is better than yours" mentality seen
in the premise "Gypsies are unreliable." Think about that for a
while.
|